EnglishFrançais
France flag

France

Employee Monitoring in France: Geolocation and Workplace Video

By Recording Law Editorial Team9 min read

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an employer geolocate an employee's vehicle at all times?

No. Geolocation is a subsidiary measure, allowed only for specific purposes such as tracking a transport service, the safety of the employee or vehicle, or optimising routes. It can only serve to check working time when no other means exists. The Cour de cassation in fact overturned a court of appeal that had validated such a use without verifying that geolocation was the only means of carrying out that check. Permanent and systematic tracking, without proportionate justification, is unlawful.

Can the vehicle be tracked outside working hours?

No. No collection of location data is allowed outside working time, which includes the home-to-work commute, break periods, and personal use of the vehicle. The employee must have the ability to switch off the geolocation during these periods. The employer may monitor how often these switch-offs occur, but it cannot track the employee once the working day is over.

How long can geolocation data be kept?

The CNIL retains three periods depending on the purpose. Retention is two months in principle. It can go up to one year where the data serves to optimise routes or to prove an intervention, when no other means of proof exists. Finally, the period is five years where the data is used to track working time, in order to comply with the legal obligations in that area.

Must the employer consult the CSE before installing cameras?

Yes, in companies with a comite social et economique, the employer must inform and consult the CSE before putting a video surveillance system in place. Each affected employee must also be individually informed, for example about the purpose of the system, its legal basis, the recipients of the images, and their rights. Video surveillance must not place a workstation under permanent surveillance, except in specific justified circumstances, and sound recording is in principle not authorised, reserved for particular situations triggered by the employee, for example an assault.

What does an employer risk by monitoring employees unlawfully?

The CNIL can issue a formal notice and then a sanction. One company was fined 10,000 euros for refusing to give an employee their own geolocation data after an accident, and for ignoring a formal notice. In another case, a fine of around 100,000 euros was reported against a chain that had installed hidden cameras in stockrooms, a figure that should be treated with caution because the decision was not consulted here. Beyond the CNIL, evidence obtained through an unlawful system may be set aside by the court.

Sources and References

  1. Code du travail, Article L1121-1 (justification and proportionality) - Legifrance(legifrance.gouv.fr).gov
  2. Code du travail, Article L1222-4 (prior notice to the employee) - Legifrance(legifrance.gouv.fr).gov
  3. CNIL - The geolocation of employees' vehicles(cnil.fr).gov
  4. CNIL - Video surveillance and video protection at work(cnil.fr).gov
  5. CNIL - The sanctions issued by the CNIL(cnil.fr).gov
  6. Code de la securite interieure, Article L252-1 (prefectoral authorisation for video protection) - Legifrance(legifrance.gouv.fr).gov
  7. Service-Public.gouv.fr - Can a geolocation system serve as proof for a dismissal?(service-public.gouv.fr).gov
  8. CNIL - The GDPR applied to the processing of employee data(cnil.fr).gov
Share: