Crime Near New York's Two Overdose Prevention Centers Showed No Significant Change in a 2023 Study. A 2024 Study Found Property Crime Up 167% Near One.

Independently fact-checkedAdam SteierBy , data analyst and senior technical partner29 min read

Independently fact-checked against primary sources (last audited November 10, 2026). · 18 primary sources cited on this page. How we verify our legal content

Updates

Reworded for readability. No figures, quotes, sources or findings changed.

Restructured as a feature: chart titles state the finding, side details moved to How we measured. Every figure and quote was re-checked against its source.

Independently fact-checked against the cited primary sources

Independently fact-checked against the cited primary sources

Sources and References

  1. NYC Office of the Mayor, release 793-21, Nation's First Overdose Prevention Center Services to Open in New York City, Nov 30 2021 (Wayback Machine capture)(web.archive.org).gov
  2. United States v. Safehouse, No. 20-1422 (3d Cir. Jan 12 2021), precedential opinion(www2.ca3.uscourts.gov).gov
  3. U.S. Department of Justice, press release on the Third Circuit Safehouse ruling, Jan 13 2021(justice.gov).gov
  4. Executive Order 14321, Ending Crime and Disorder on America's Streets, July 24 2025, Federal Register(govinfo.gov).gov
  5. Chalfin, del Pozo and Mitre-Becerril, Overdose Prevention Centers, Crime, and Disorder in New York City, JAMA Network Open (2023)(pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).gov
  6. Harocopos et al., First 2 Months of Operation at First Publicly Recognized Overdose Prevention Centers in US, JAMA Network Open (2022)(pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).gov
  7. Allen et al., Overdose Prevention Centers and Neighborhood Commercial Activity in New York City, JAMA Network Open (2026)(pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).gov
  8. Hall and Ratcliffe, Assessing the impact of safe consumption sites on neighborhood crime in New York City: a synthetic control approach, Journal of Experimental Criminology (2024), abstract(link.springer.com)
  9. Allen et al., Considerations for the epidemiological evaluation of hyperlocal interventions: the New York City overdose prevention centers, Social Science & Medicine (2025), abstract(midasnetwork.us)
  10. CDUHR (NYU), Changes in community-level pedestrian stops following overdose prevention center implementation in New York City, abstract(cduhr.org)
  11. National Institute on Drug Abuse, Overdose Prevention Centers(nida.nih.gov).gov
  12. NYC Health Department, Epi Data Brief No. 150, Unintentional Drug Poisoning (Overdose) Deaths in New York City in 2024 (Oct 2025)(home4.nyc.gov).gov
  13. NYC Open Data, NYPD Complaint Data Historic(data.cityofnewyork.us).gov
  14. NYC Open Data, NYPD Complaint Data Current Year to Date(data.cityofnewyork.us).gov
  15. NYC Open Data, NYPD Arrests Data Historic(data.cityofnewyork.us).gov
  16. NYC Open Data, NYPD Arrests Data Year to Date(data.cityofnewyork.us).gov
  17. OnPoint NYC, Year One annual report (operator)(onpointnyc.org)
  18. OnPoint NYC, Year Two impact report (operator)(onpointnyc.org)
  19. OnPoint NYC, Year Three impact report (operator)(onpointnyc.org)
  20. OnPoint NYC, Four Years of Saving Lives (operator, Jan 8 2026)(onpointnyc.org)
  21. OnPoint NYC, release on 2,000 overdose interventions (operator, May 2026)(onpointnyc.org)
  22. Crain's New York Business, Overdose Prevention Centers Sheltered Hundreds During New York's Coldest Weekend, Feb 11 2026 (reprint hosted by OnPoint NYC)(onpointnyc.org)
  23. New York Amsterdam News, New supervised injection sites cause controversy in uptown neighborhoods, Dec 9 2021(amsterdamnews.com)
  24. 1010 WINS, Rev. Al Sharpton's group to protest de Blasio's safe injection sites, Dec 8 2021(audacy.com)
  25. Rep. Nicole Malliotakis, press release, Nov 30 2021(malliotakis.house.gov).gov
  26. Axios, Nov 30 2021(axios.com)
  27. PIX11, Overdose prevention centers want input as DOJ weighs future, Feb 8 2022(digital-release.pix11.com)
  28. THE CITY, Harlem locals at odds on first anniversary of America's first safe injection site, Dec 13 2022(thecity.nyc)
  29. Gothamist, Overdose prevention centers did not increase crime in NYC neighborhoods, study finds, Nov 2023(gothamist.com)
  30. City & State New York, After Damian Williams' striking comments on supervised injection sites, Aug 2023(cityandstateny.com)
  31. CBS New York, Federal prosecutor threatens to shut down New York City overdose prevention centers, Aug 9 2023(cbsnews.com)
  32. Housing Works, press release, Aug 9 2023 (advocacy organization)(housingworks.org)
  33. New York Post via AOL, NYC residents beg Trump admin to close controversial safe injection site, Feb 23 2025(aol.com)
  34. WABC-TV (ABC7 New York), Feb 2025(abc7ny.com)
  35. STAT, on OnPoint NYC's fourth anniversary, Dec 18 2025(statnews.com)
  36. CBS News, on OnPoint NYC and its neighborhoods, Aug 7 2026(cbsnews.com)
  37. Fox News Digital, House Republican urges AG Blanche to shut down NYC injection sites, Aug 13 2026(foxnews.com)
  38. WBUR / The Public's Radio, Providence supervised consumption center opens, Dec 11 2024(wbur.org)
  39. Rhode Island General Assembly, press release on 2023-S 0026(rilegislature.gov).gov
  40. Rhode Island Current, Four years after R.I. lawmakers OK safe injection site program, they're still debating its merits, Apr 2 2025(rhodeislandcurrent.com)
  41. R.I. Gen. Laws 23-12.10-1, harm reduction center pilot program(webserver.rilegislature.gov).gov
  42. Project Weber/RENEW, A Year of Saving Lives (operator, Jan 2026)(weberrenew.org)
  43. Vermont Department of Health, Act 178 (2024) progress report on the Burlington overdose prevention center, May 2025(legislature.vermont.gov).gov
  44. WCAX, Hurdles remain for Burlington's overdose-prevention center, Oct 7 2026(wcax.com)
  45. FOX 5 NY, NYPD operation aims to improve East Harlem quality of life (Operation Four Corners), Oct 26 2023(fox5ny.com)
  46. Congress.gov, H.R. 172 (119th Congress), Defund Heroin Injection Centers Act of 2025; latest action Jan 3 2025, referred to the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform (checked Nov 10 2026)(congress.gov).gov
Share: