Mortgage Denials Were About Three Times as High at 50-60% Debt-to-Income as at the CFPB's Former 43% Line (2018-2025)

Independently fact-checkedAdam SteierBy , data analyst and senior technical partner27 min read

Independently fact-checked against primary sources (last audited November 10, 2026). · 19 primary sources cited on this page. How we verify our legal content

Updates

Reworded for readability. No figures, quotes, sources or findings changed.

Restructured as a feature: chart titles state the finding, side details moved to How we measured. Every figure and quote was re-checked against its source.

Independently fact-checked against the cited primary sources

Independently fact-checked against the cited primary sources

Sources and References

  1. CFPB/FFIEC HMDA Data Browser, nationwide home-purchase loan-level data, 2018-2025 (retrieved Oct 31 and Nov 7, 2026)(ffiec.cfpb.gov).gov
  2. HMDA Data Browser API, 2025 home-purchase counts by action taken(ffiec.cfpb.gov).gov
  3. Manu García and Carlos Garriga, What 30 Million Applications Reveal About Mortgage Denial Thresholds, St. Louis Fed On the Economy, June 4, 2026(stlouisfed.org)
  4. García and Garriga, The Determinants of Mortgage Denial Using Public Data, St. Louis Fed Working Paper 2026-007 (April 29, 2026)(fedinprint.org)
  5. CFPB, Prepared Remarks of Richard Cordray at the Ability-to-Repay Rule Field Hearing, Jan 10, 2013(consumerfinance.gov).gov
  6. CFPB blog, field hearing notice for Baltimore, Jan 10, 2013(consumerfinance.gov).gov
  7. Ability-to-Repay and Qualified Mortgage Standards final rule, 78 FR 6408 (Jan 30, 2013)(federalregister.gov).gov
  8. 15 U.S.C. 1639c (Truth in Lending Act section 129C, added by the Dodd-Frank Act)(law.cornell.edu)
  9. CFPB, Ability-to-Repay Rule: Fact vs. Fiction (December 2013)(files.consumerfinance.gov).gov
  10. CFPB, Ability-to-Repay and Qualified Mortgage Rule Assessment Report (January 2019)(files.consumerfinance.gov).gov
  11. Qualified Mortgage Definition (General QM Loan Definition) final rule, 85 FR 86308 (Dec 29, 2020)(federalregister.gov).gov
  12. CFPB rule page, General QM Loan Definition(consumerfinance.gov).gov
  13. CFPB press release, Dec 10, 2020(consumerfinance.gov).gov
  14. Delay of mandatory compliance date, 86 FR 22844 (Apr 30, 2021)(federalregister.gov).gov
  15. CFPB press release, Apr 27, 2021(consumerfinance.gov).gov
  16. CFPB public statement on General QM and Seasoned QM final rules, 86 FR 11623 (Feb 26, 2021)(federalregister.gov).gov
  17. Truth in Lending annual threshold adjustments, FR Doc 2025-22773 (Dec 15, 2025)(federalregister.gov).gov
  18. Fannie Mae Lender Letter LL-2021-09, Apr 8, 2021(singlefamily.fanniemae.com)
  19. Freddie Mac Guide Bulletin 2021-13, Apr 8, 2021 (lender-hosted mirror; guide.freddiemac.com requires login)(tenaco.com)
  20. Mortgage Bankers Association comment letter to the CFPB, July 9, 2012(consumerfinancemonitor.com)
  21. Talk Business & Politics, New mortgage qualification rules unveiled, January 2013(talkbusiness.net)
  22. Inman News, Jan 10, 2013(inman.com)
  23. The Real Deal, Qualified mortgage rules go into effect, Jan 10, 2014(therealdeal.com)
  24. Written statement of Bill Emerson, House Financial Services subcommittee hearing, Jan 14, 2014(financialservices.house.gov).gov
  25. National Association of Realtors, statement for the record, Jan 14, 2014 hearing(narfocus.com)
  26. W. Scott Frame, Kristopher Gerardi, Daniel Sexton and Joseph Tracy, Dallas Fed Economics, Mar 24, 2020(dallasfed.org)
  27. Kate Berry, Consumer groups, lenders find common cause against CFPB mortgage provision, American Banker/National Mortgage News, Aug 27, 2019(nationalmortgagenews.com)
  28. HousingWire, Housing industry calls for end of QM patch DTI limit, Sept 17, 2019(housingwire.com)
  29. Consumer, civil-rights and fair-housing coalition letter to CFPB Director Kraninger, Sept 10, 2019(consumerfed.org)
  30. Independent Banker (ICBA), ICBA offers alternative to redefining QM (2020)(independentbanker.org)
  31. MBA statement on CFPB final General QM and Seasoned QM rules, December 2020(newslink.mba.org)
  32. Center for Responsible Lending and National Fair Housing Alliance joint statement, Dec 11, 2020(nationalfairhousing.org)
  33. MBA Newslink, MBA Urges No Delay to CFPB QM Final Rule (April 2021)(newslink.mba.org)
  34. 24 CFR 203.19, FHA qualified mortgage definition(ecfr.gov).gov
  35. HUD Mortgagee Letter 2014-02, FHA manual underwriting(hud.gov).gov
  36. HUD press release 13-188, Dec 11, 2013(archives.hud.gov).gov
  37. 38 CFR 36.4340, VA underwriting standards(ecfr.gov).gov
  38. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02, Debt-to-Income Ratios (04/02/2025)(selling-guide.fanniemae.com)
  39. Center for Responsible Lending, About CRL(responsiblelending.org)
Share: