Fifth Circuit Vacates Injunction on Mississippi Age Verification Law
Independently fact-checked against primary sources (last audited November 20, 2026). · 8 primary sources cited on this page. How we verify our legal content

The Fifth Circuit vacated the preliminary injunction against Mississippi's Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act on November 19, 2026, holding in NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348, that NetChoice failed to substantiate its as-applied First Amendment challenge platform by platform. The panel did not hold the Act constitutional.
Information last verified on November 20, 2026. This is a developing story; we update it as the record changes.
Jurisdiction scope: This article addresses the Fifth Circuit's November 19, 2026 preliminary-injunction ruling on Mississippi House Bill 1126 and the federal First Amendment framework the panel applied. It does not address state obscenity or pornography-site age-gate statutes, platform liability for user content, or the separate Mississippi criminal provisions on child exploitation beyond noting what the Act amended.
What Happened
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit released a published opinion on November 19, 2026 in NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348, an appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, USDC No. 1:24-CV-170. The panel was Circuit Judges Richman, Engelhardt and Wilson. Judge Cory T. Wilson wrote for the panel. No judge concurred separately and no judge dissented.
The court vacated the district court's second preliminary injunction against the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act and remanded for further proceedings. The Act is codified, the panel noted, at Miss. Code Ann. sections 45-38-1 to 45-38-13 (2024), with an enforcement hook at Miss. Code Ann. section 75-24-5 (2025).
The litigation has now produced two Fifth Circuit opinions. Mississippi enacted House Bill 1126 in the 2024 regular session, naming it for Walker Montgomery, a 16-year-old Mississippian who, the opinion recounts, committed suicide after he was the target of a sextortion plot by online predators (slip op. at 2). NetChoice, a trade association of internet companies, sued before the Act took effect and won a preliminary injunction on a facial First Amendment theory. That decision is reported at NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 738 F. Supp. 3d 753, 761 (S.D. Miss. 2024). The Supreme Court decided Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707 (2024), the same day. The Fifth Circuit then vacated that first injunction and sent the case back so the district court could apply Moody's method, in NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 24-60341 (5th Cir. Apr. 17, 2025), reported at 134 F.4th 799 and referred to in the new opinion as Fitch I.
On remand, NetChoice amended its complaint. According to the panel, the amendment added one paragraph alleging that the Act is unconstitutional as applied to NetChoice members and their regulated services, and otherwise did no more than interlineate the phrase "as applied" through the existing pleading (slip op. at 3). NetChoice then renewed its injunction request on an as-applied basis, relying on a new declaration from its General Counsel, Bartlett Cleland, plus three declarations already in the record from Alexandra Veitch of YouTube, Gautham Pai of Nextdoor and Denise Paolucci of Dreamwidth. The panel found nothing else in the record about how the Act would operate against the member platforms.
The district court again enjoined the Act in its entirety, this time limited to nine NetChoice member platforms: Reddit, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, X, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth (slip op. at 4 n.1). Justice Kavanaugh's later concurrence dates that order to June 18, 2025. Mississippi appealed and asked the Fifth Circuit to stay the injunction pending appeal; the court granted the stay on July 17, 2025. NetChoice applied to the Supreme Court to vacate the stay, and on August 14, 2025 the Court denied the application in No. 25A97, reported at 606 U.S. 994.
The panel's reasoning in the new opinion is narrow and evidentiary. It held that a plaintiff pressing an as-applied challenge bears the burden of producing the facts behind the challenge, that "a developed factual record is essential," and that particularized facts are what let a court craft narrow relief. Measured against that standard, the panel said, the record did not even establish that the Act applies to every platform NetChoice listed. The four declarations "fail to show with any particularity how the services will be affected by the Act" (slip op. at 10). As to X, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, Reddit and Snapchat, the panel found no record detail about which products are covered or how. It used X as its illustration, listing the For You feed, the Following feed, direct messaging, advertising and sponsorship products, a shopping platform and the Grok artificial-intelligence feature, and noting that nothing in the record or the injunction identified which of those the Act reaches. The panel cited X's own public business page for that product inventory, and cited Meta's, Reddit's and Pinterest's business pages as examples that those companies maintain other significant functionality, each marked last visited November 18, 2026.
The panel then turned on the shape of the relief:
"Finally, the scope of the injunction at issue does not bear the hallmarks of an as-applied injunction. Rather, it is strikingly facial." Source: NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348, slip op. at 13 (5th Cir. Nov. 19, 2026)
The district court's own analysis of which platforms and functions the Act covers, the panel observed, "is confined to a single paragraph," which the opinion reproduces in full at slip op. at 12. The conclusion states the holding precisely:
"Because NetChoice failed to substantiate, with the required granularity, how the Act is unconstitutional as applied to its individual members, the record before us does not support the district court's second, as-applied injunction entered in this case. As an outgrowth of that deficiency, the district court likewise did not appropriately tailor the relief it awarded NetChoice." Source: NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348, slip op. at 14 (5th Cir. Nov. 19, 2026)
Two things the panel expressly did not decide are worth stating plainly. It did not hold that House Bill 1126 is constitutional, as applied or otherwise; it described the relief the district court entered as "at least premature, if not unwarranted" (slip op. at 9). And it rejected Mississippi's argument that the district court had defied the Fitch I mandate, saying it disagreed with that assertion "particularly given the 'murky' state of the law in this area" (slip op. at 13 n.5).

What the Law Actually Says
One labeling point first. The section numbers in this part are House Bill 1126's own bill sections, which is how the Fifth Circuit's opinion cites them. They are not Mississippi Code section numbers: the Act's substantive provisions are codified within Miss. Code Ann. sections 45-38-1 to 45-38-13, so a reader searching the Mississippi Code for a bill section number will not find these duties under that number.
House Bill 1126 took effect July 1, 2024 under Section 10 of the Act. Its coverage test, in Section 3(1) of the Act, reaches a digital service provider whose service does all three of the following: connects users so they can socially interact with other users; allows a user to create a public, semi-public or private profile for signing in; and allows a user to create or post content other users can view, including on a message board, a chat room, or a landing page, video channel or main feed carrying other users' content. Section 3(2) excludes, among others, a provider processing or maintaining user data in connection with the user's employment, promotion, reassignment or retention as an employee or independent contractor, to the extent the data is processed or maintained for that purpose, and a service that facilitates only email or direct messaging. The opinion summarizes the exclusions as covering platforms offering access to "news, sports, commerce, [or] online video games" with only incidental interactive or chat functions, plus platforms providing access to career development opportunities (slip op. at 2).
Three duties sit at the center of the dispute. Section 4(1) bars a provider from entering an account agreement unless the person has registered an age, and requires the provider to "make commercially reasonable efforts to verify the age of the person creating an account with a level of certainty appropriate to the risks" of its own information-management practices. Note that this applies to everyone opening an account, not only minors. Section 4(2) prohibits letting a known minor hold an account without express parental or guardian consent, and lists acceptable consent methods including a signed returned form, a toll-free call, a video conference, or collection and then deletion of parent identification data. Section 6(1) requires commercially reasonable efforts to develop and implement a strategy to prevent or mitigate a known minor's exposure to harmful material and content promoting or facilitating enumerated harms, among them self-harm, eating disorders, substance use disorders, suicidal behaviors, stalking, online bullying, grooming, trafficking and incitement of violence. Section 6(2) says that subsection does not require a provider to block a minor who deliberately and independently searches for content, or to block prevention resources.
Section 5 adds data limits for known minors: collection and use confined to what is reasonably necessary for the service and the original purpose, no precise geolocation collection, no targeted advertising involving harmful material, and no sharing, disclosing or selling of the minor's personal identifying information except where the Act requires it, such as a subpoena, a law enforcement investigation, or blocking unlawful or harmful material. Section 2(c) defines harmful material by cross-reference to Miss. Code section 11-77-3(d).
Enforcement is split. Section 8 amended Miss. Code section 75-24-5 to add violating Sections 1 through 7 of the Act to the list of unfair or deceptive trade practices, which routes public enforcement through the Attorney General's consumer-protection authority. Section 7 says the Act generally creates no private right of action, but lets a parent or guardian of an affected known minor seek a declaratory judgment or an injunction against the provider, and bars class certification of such a suit. Section 9 separately amended Miss. Code section 97-5-31 so that "morphed" depictions count as sexually explicit conduct in the child-exploitation definitions. The panel summarized the overall exposure as civil monetary penalties and criminal liability (slip op. at 3). For the statute broken down provision by provision, see our standing explainer on how Mississippi structured HB 1126.
The constitutional framework is where this ruling actually bites. Moody did not change what the First Amendment forbids so much as how a court must test a challenge. For a facial challenge, a plaintiff must establish that "a substantial number of [the law's] applications are unconstitutional, judged in relation to the statute's plainly legitimate sweep," Moody, 603 U.S. at 723. An as-applied challenge is the narrower road: the plaintiff "generally cannot prevail on an as-applied challenge without showing that the law has in fact been (or is sufficiently likely to be) unconstitutionally applied to him," McCullen v. Coakley, 573 U.S. 464, 485 n.4 (2014), and the court confines its analysis to the statute as applied to that plaintiff. The classification matters because, as the panel put it quoting Bucklew v. Precythe, 587 U.S. 119, 138 (2019), it "affects the extent to which the invalidity of the challenged law must be demonstrated and the corresponding 'breadth of the remedy.'"
That is the structural problem a trade association runs into. NetChoice is not a platform. It sued on behalf of members whose products differ from one another, and an as-applied showing has to be built from each member's facts. The panel leaned on Fifth Circuit precedent that particularized facts are what permit narrowly tailored relief, Justice v. Hosemann, 771 F.3d 285, 292 (5th Cir. 2014), that the "hallmarks" of an as-applied remedy are "dependability and a limited scope," id. at 294, and that the plaintiff must "produce the facts upon which [it] bases [its] challenge," In re Cao, 619 F.3d 410, 434 (5th Cir. 2010) (en banc). It also drew on Moody's own self-limitation: the Supreme Court analyzed Texas's law only as applied to Facebook's NewsFeed and YouTube's homepage and said nothing about other applications, 603 U.S. at 727, and did not extend even to other products of those same companies, id. at 734. A total injunction, the panel added citing LIA Network v. City of Kerrville, 163 F.4th 147, 162 (5th Cir. 2025), is "the quintessential facial relief."
Finally, posture. This is a preliminary-injunction appeal, reviewed for abuse of discretion, under the four-factor test of Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., 555 U.S. 7, 20, 22 (2008), which calls a preliminary injunction "an extraordinary remedy that may only be awarded upon a clear showing that the plaintiff is entitled to such relief." Nothing decided on November 19, 2026 is a final merits judgment about House Bill 1126. Mississippi sits inside a much wider legislative wave; our state-by-state tracker of age verification rules maps the variations, and a separate set of bills tries to move the age check off the platform entirely by putting the obligation on app stores.

Is Mississippi's Law Enforceable Right Now?
We cannot confirm the enforcement posture as of November 20, 2026, and we are not going to guess at it.
Here is what the record does support. The injunction the district court entered in June 2025 had already been stayed by the Fifth Circuit on July 17, 2025, and the Supreme Court declined to vacate that stay on August 14, 2025. So for roughly sixteen months before this opinion issued, that injunction was not operating. The November 19, 2026 judgment vacates it outright and returns the case to the district court.
What we could not verify is everything that stands between a vacatur and an enforceable statute. A court of appeals judgment does not take effect against the district court until the mandate issues. Under Fed. R. App. P. 41(b), the mandate must issue 7 days after the time to file a petition for rehearing expires, or 7 days after an order denying a timely rehearing petition or a motion to stay the mandate, whichever is later, and under Rule 41(c) it is effective when issued. The Fifth Circuit's internal operating procedure following Rule 41 says mandates issue promptly on the 7th day after the rehearing window closes, absent a stay. Under Fed. R. App. P. 40(d)(1) the rehearing window here is 14 days from entry of judgment, because no party is the United States, a United States agency or a federal officer. By our own count from that rule, and not from any date the court has set, that window closes on December 3, 2026.
Neither period is fixed. Rule 40(d)(1) applies unless the time is shortened or extended by order or local rule, Rule 41(b) adds that the court may shorten or extend the time by order, and the Fifth Circuit's own procedure, which conditions prompt issuance on the absence of a stay, also lets any active judge of the court ask that a mandate be withheld. The rule-based timetable is a default rather than a fixed schedule.
Whether anyone filed, whether the mandate has issued, and whether the district court has entered any new relief on remand are all docket facts we could not reach: the Fifth Circuit's public site posts no further document in No. 25-60348, and the appellate docket itself is behind PACER.
Three things would settle the question, and nothing short of them should be treated as settling it: a docket entry showing the mandate issued; an order resolving or confirming the absence of a rehearing or rehearing en banc petition; and whatever the district court does on remand, including any narrower injunction NetChoice may seek. Anyone with a compliance decision riding on this should read the live docket rather than this article.
Analysis: Why This Matters
The following is analysis from the Recording Law Editorial Team.
The most important feature of this opinion is what it is not about. It is not a ruling that age verification survives the First Amendment. It is a ruling about the evidentiary record. Judge Wilson's opinion repeatedly returns to the same gap: the record did not say which functions of which platforms the Act reaches, so the district court had nothing from which to build narrow relief and the appellate court had nothing meaningful to review. The panel invoked the Fifth Circuit's line that it is "a court of review, not first view."
That makes this a decision about litigation architecture, and it lands on a model the technology industry has used repeatedly. A trade association can sue faster and more cheaply than nine separate platforms can, and it can keep individual companies out of discovery about their own products. Moody already strained that model by demanding application-by-application analysis for facial challenges. This opinion extends the strain to the as-applied route a concurrence in Moody had pointed toward: Justice Barrett's Moody concurrence, which the panel quotes, suggested NetChoice's members "would be better served by bringing a First Amendment challenge as applied to those functions." The Fifth Circuit's answer is that the as-applied road is open but it is paved with per-member, per-function, per-section evidence, and an association that pleads "as applied" without developing that evidence has changed its label rather than its case.
There is a real and visible tension in the case that readers should see rather than have smoothed over. On August 14, 2025, in the same litigation, Justice Kavanaugh wrote separately to say that "under this Court's case law as it currently stands, the Mississippi law is likely unconstitutional," and that he concurred in denying NetChoice interim relief only because NetChoice had not sufficiently shown that the balance of harms and equities favored it. He listed seven other federal district courts that had enjoined comparable state laws. That is one Justice's view in an interim-relief posture, and it binds nobody. But it means the Fifth Circuit's November 2026 ruling resolved an evidentiary failure in a case where a member of the Supreme Court had already signaled a merits view in the opposite direction. We are not predicting how the remand, any rehearing petition, or any eventual merits ruling comes out, and nobody should read either signal as a forecast.
One detail is worth flagging for its own sake. A court reaching outside the record, to the companies' own public business pages, in order to demonstrate the record's inadequacy is an unusually pointed way of saying the evidentiary burden was not met.
How This Affects You
For readers in Mississippi, nothing in this opinion creates a new obligation on an individual user, and nothing in it establishes that the Act is valid. The practical question for a Mississippi family is whether covered platforms are running age registration and parental-consent flows, which is a function of enforcement posture and company compliance choices rather than of this ruling alone.
For anyone operating a covered digital service, the compliance question turns on docket facts this article cannot supply. The Act's coverage test in Section 3(1) is conjunctive, so whether a given service is covered at all depends on satisfying all three elements, and the Section 3(2) exclusions matter. Those are provision-level questions for counsel who can look at the specific product.
For readers tracking the national picture, challengers to these statutes now face a demanding evidentiary route in the Fifth Circuit regardless of how strong the underlying First Amendment argument may be. That is a procedural development with substantive consequences, and it says nothing about how any particular state's law will fare.
What Happens Next
The case returns to the Southern District of Mississippi. The Fifth Circuit's instructions are specific. NetChoice must substantiate, with specificity, how each section of the Act is unconstitutional as applied "member-by-member, function-by-function, and statutory section-by-section" (slip op. at 13). If it makes that showing, the district court must then determine in like specificity whether and how the Act violates the First Amendment as applied, including a factual analysis of the commercially reasonable effort the Act demands of each individual member seeking relief, a task the panel traced back to Fitch I, 134 F.4th at 809.
On the appellate side the sequence is set by rule, subject to the court's power to shorten or extend either period, on the timetable described above. We will update this article when the docket shows the mandate, any rehearing filing, or any new district-court order. That docket activity, not commentary, is what will make the enforcement question answerable.
This is general legal information, not legal advice. It covers Mississippi and federal First Amendment law in the Fifth Circuit, and reflects sources verified on November 20, 2026. Laws change and this story is developing; consult a lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction about your specific situation.
Related articles
Last updated: 2026-11-20. This is a developing story; details verified as of 2026-11-20.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Fifth Circuit rule that Mississippi's age verification law is constitutional?
No. The November 19, 2026 opinion in NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348, holds only that NetChoice failed to substantiate its as-applied First Amendment challenge with the required granularity and that the district court did not tailor its injunction. The panel called the relief entered below 'at least premature, if not unwarranted' and remanded. It did not rule on whether House Bill 1126 complies with the First Amendment.
Is Mississippi House Bill 1126 being enforced right now?
We could not confirm the enforcement posture as of November 20, 2026. The injunction had already been stayed by the Fifth Circuit on July 17, 2025, and the Supreme Court declined to vacate that stay on August 14, 2025, so it was not operating before this opinion. The new judgment vacates it, but a court of appeals judgment reaches the district court only when the mandate issues under Fed. R. App. P. 41(b), and the appellate docket is behind PACER. Check the live docket rather than relying on any summary.
What is the difference between a facial and an as-applied First Amendment challenge?
A facial challenge attacks the statute across its applications. Under Moody v. NetChoice, LLC, 603 U.S. 707, 723 (2024), the plaintiff must establish that a substantial number of the law's applications are unconstitutional, judged against the statute's plainly legitimate sweep. An as-applied challenge attacks the statute only as it operates against the particular plaintiff, which under McCullen v. Coakley, 573 U.S. 464, 485 n.4 (2014), requires showing the law has been or is sufficiently likely to be unconstitutionally applied to that plaintiff. The classification drives how much must be demonstrated and how broad any remedy can be.
Which platforms did the vacated injunction cover?
The district court's second preliminary injunction barred enforcement of the entire Act as to nine NetChoice member platforms: Reddit, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, X, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth. The Fifth Circuit noted that record evidence addressed only YouTube, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth, plus a general declaration from NetChoice's General Counsel, and that nothing in the record described how the Act applies to the other six.
What does Mississippi House Bill 1126 require platforms to do?
Section 4(1) of House Bill 1126 requires covered providers to have account creators register an age and to make commercially reasonable efforts to verify it. Section 4(2) bars letting a known minor hold an account without express parental or guardian consent and lists acceptable consent methods. Section 6(1) requires commercially reasonable efforts to develop and implement a strategy to prevent or mitigate a known minor's exposure to harmful material and listed harms. Section 5 limits collection and use of a known minor's personal identifying information, including a ban on collecting precise geolocation.
Can a parent sue a platform under House Bill 1126?
Section 7 of the Act says it generally provides no basis for a private right of action, but subsection (2) lets the parent or guardian of an affected known minor bring an action seeking a declaratory judgment under Rule 57 of the Mississippi Rules of Civil Procedure or an injunction against the provider. Section 7(3) bars a court from certifying such an action as a class action. Public enforcement runs through the Attorney General, because Section 8 made violations of Sections 1 through 7 an unfair or deceptive trade practice under Miss. Code section 75-24-5.
What did Justice Kavanaugh say about the Mississippi law?
On August 14, 2025, when the Supreme Court denied NetChoice's application to vacate the Fifth Circuit's stay in No. 25A97, Justice Kavanaugh concurred separately. He wrote that in his view NetChoice had demonstrated it was likely to succeed on the merits, that 'under this Court's case law as it currently stands, the Mississippi law is likely unconstitutional,' and that he nonetheless concurred in the denial because NetChoice had not sufficiently demonstrated that the balance of harms and equities favored it at that time. That is one Justice's view in an interim-relief posture and is not a holding of the Court.
What happens next in NetChoice v. Fitch?
The case returns to the Southern District of Mississippi, where the Fifth Circuit directed that NetChoice must substantiate unconstitutionality member-by-member, function-by-function and statutory section-by-section, and that the district court must then make correspondingly specific findings, including on what commercially reasonable efforts the Act demands of each member. On the appellate side, the rehearing window under Fed. R. App. P. 40(d)(1) runs 14 days from the November 19, 2026 judgment, and the mandate issues under Rule 41(b) seven days after that window closes or after an order denying a timely petition, though the court may shorten or extend either period by order. We are not predicting any of those outcomes.
Updates
Independently fact-checked against the cited primary sources
Sources and References
- NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348, slip op. at 2 to 4, 9 to 14 (5th Cir. Nov. 19, 2026) (published opinion of Wilson, J., joined by Richman and Engelhardt, JJ., vacating the renewed preliminary injunction against the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act and remanding)(ca5.uscourts.gov).gov
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, Opinions RSS feed, entry for No. 25-60348 NetChoice v. Fitch, 'Published Opinion, Released November 19, 2026' (pubDate Thu, 19 Nov 2026 12:05:04 -0600)(ca5.uscourts.gov).gov
- NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 24-60341, slip op. at 1, 13 to 15 (5th Cir. Apr. 17, 2025) (Higginbotham, J.; Ho, J., concurring in the judgment), reported at 134 F.4th 799, vacating the first preliminary injunction and remanding for application of Moody(ca5.uscourts.gov).gov
- Mississippi House Bill 1126, 2024 Regular Session (As Sent to Governor), Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act, secs. 2(c), 3(1) to (2), 4(1) to (2), 5, 6(1) to (2), 7, 8 (adding Miss. Code sec. 75-24-5(2)(q)), 9 and 10 (effective July 1, 2024)(billstatus.ls.state.ms.us).gov
- Supreme Court of the United States, Docket No. 25A97, NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, Attorney General of Mississippi (docketed July 23, 2025; application to vacate stay denied August 14, 2025, Justice Kavanaugh concurring in the denial)(supremecourt.gov).gov
- NetChoice, LLC v. Fitch, 606 U.S. 994, 994 to 995 (2025) (Kavanaugh, J., concurring in the denial of the application to vacate stay), in Orders of the Court, 606 U.S. Part 2 preliminary print, at PDF pages 74 to 75(supremecourt.gov).gov
- Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure (Dec. 1, 2024), Rule 40(d)(1) (petition for panel rehearing or rehearing en banc due within 14 days after judgment is entered; 45 days only where the United States or a federal officer is a party) and Rule 41(b) to (c) (mandate issues 7 days after the rehearing window expires and is effective when issued), at 44 to 46(uscourts.gov).gov
- Rules and Internal Operating Procedures of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit (Dec. 2025), 5th Cir. R. 40.1.4 (time for filing governed by Fed. R. App. P. 40(d)(1)) and the I.O.P. following Fed. R. App. P. 41 (mandates issue promptly on the 7th day after the time for filing a petition for rehearing expires), at 38(ca5.uscourts.gov).gov